Product Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray Review: A Compact Oven Air-Frying Set

A good fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in a standard or convection oven without adding a countertop air fryer.

This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

In gotham steel air fryer reviews, this two-piece crisper tray stands out as an oven accessory for cooks who want air-fried-style circulation without adding another appliance.

Its raised mesh basket and solid drip pan are designed for baking, roasting, reheating, and air-fry settings.

Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary

The quick verdict

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A good fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in a standard or convection oven without adding a countertop air fryer.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round 13.12-inch overall size, designed for standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air-fry models.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper finish.
  • The pan catches grease and crumbs that fall through the basket.

Pros

  • The raised basket supports airflow around food while the lower pan catches drips.
  • Can be used across several oven cooking modes rather than serving only as a dedicated air-fry tray.

Consider before buying

  • A round 13.12-inch cooking area may require multiple rounds when preparing larger portions.
  • The basket and pan need to fit together on a usable oven rack; measure the rack opening and available depth before buying.
Read the full review summary

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray pairs a raised basket with a solid pan underneath, giving air room to circulate around food while catching crumbs and drips.

Its 13.12-inch round shape is intended for standard oven racks, smaller convection ovens, and oven air-fry setups, making it a potentially useful choice for compact batches and everyday sides.

The appeal is its multi-purpose format: one set can serve as a crisper, roasting rack, or baking pan, and the coated aluminum pieces are dishwasher safe.

Buyers should check the usable rack space in their oven and consider whether a round basket offers enough surface area for the portions they usually make.

The buying factors

Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard

Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.

8/10

Oven versatility

The set is intended for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat cooking in standard or convection ovens.

8/10

Air circulation design

The elevated mesh basket leaves space beneath and around food for heat to circulate.

8/10

Mess control

A solid pan beneath the basket catches grease and crumbs during cooking.

8/10

Cleanup convenience

Both pieces have a nonstick coating and are described as dishwasher safe.

6/10

Capacity flexibility

The round 13.12-inch footprint suits compact setups, but may limit batch size for larger households.

7/10

Material and coating

Aluminum construction and a titanium-and-ceramic coating offer a lightweight, coated alternative to an uncoated pan.

Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round 13.12-inch overall size, designed for standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air-fry models.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper finish.
  • The pan catches grease and crumbs that fall through the basket.
  • Designed for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings.
  • Dishwasher safe; the coating is described as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.

Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray

Pros

  • The raised basket supports airflow around food while the lower pan catches drips.
  • Can be used across several oven cooking modes rather than serving only as a dedicated air-fry tray.
  • A compact round footprint may be convenient in smaller ovens and alongside other ovenware.
  • Nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction make cleanup straightforward.

Consider before buying

  • A round 13.12-inch cooking area may require multiple rounds when preparing larger portions.
  • The basket and pan need to fit together on a usable oven rack; measure the rack opening and available depth before buying.
  • The nonstick coating makes gentle handling and care instructions worth checking if you prefer metal utensils or abrasive cleaning tools.

Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?

Good fit

Consider this tray if you already use an oven or convection oven and want a dedicated raised surface for crisping smaller batches.

The mesh basket lifts food above the pan, so air can reach more sides while drippings collect underneath instead of landing directly on the oven floor.

It also makes sense if you want one accessory for several oven tasks.

You can use the set for baking, roasting, or reheating as well as air-fry settings, and its round shape may fit more easily into a compact oven than a large rectangular pan.

Who should skip it

Look elsewhere if you routinely cook large batches in one go or need a broad rectangular surface for long or bulky foods.

Check the tray's diameter against your oven rack and compare it with the food portions you commonly prepare before deciding.

This set is designed for oven use, so it is not a replacement for a standalone countertop air fryer when you specifically want a separate appliance with its own basket and controls.

How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits Oven Air-Frying

Raised mesh and the lower pan

The basket-and-pan layout separates food from the solid surface below it. That arrangement gives circulating oven heat a path around the food and gives grease and crumbs somewhere to collect, which can simplify both cooking and cleanup.

A compact round footprint

At 13.12 inches round, the set is aimed at standard racks and smaller convection or oven air-fry setups.

The round shape can be handy where rack space is limited, though buyers should compare its usable area with the amount they want to cook at once.

Coating and care

The aluminum pieces use a titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating, and the set is dishwasher safe. As with coated cookware generally, buyers who use metal tools or abrasive scrubbers should check the care guidance so the surface suits their routine.

One tray for several oven jobs

Air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat use gives the set a broader role than a single-purpose crisping rack. It can help consolidate oven accessories, provided the round cooking area matches the foods and portions in regular rotation.

Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray

Grill Baskets alternative

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
4.6/5

700+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Cave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket

Choose the Gotham Steel set for a coated oven crisper with a dedicated drip pan. Consider Cave Tools if you want a stainless-steel basket suited to grilling small foods over a backyard grill.

  • The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless-steel grill basket for vegetables, fruit, seafood, and meat; it is dishwasher safe and described as oven safe.
  • The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat use, with a round mesh basket over a drip pan.

Grill Baskets alternative

Kona Extra Large Grill Basket
4.6/5

1,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Kona Extra Large Grill Basket

The Gotham Steel set better matches indoor oven crisping and catching drips. The Kona may suit buyers who need a larger basket for vegetables on an outdoor grill.

  • The Kona is an extra-large nonstick outdoor grill basket measuring 14 by 13 by 4 inches, designed for serving vegetables at gatherings.
  • The Gotham Steel tray is a 13.12-inch round set intended for oven cooking and air-fry settings.

Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?

The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if your goal is to air-fry, roast, or reheat modest portions in an oven you already own.

Its elevated mesh basket, drip-catching pan, and dishwasher-safe coated construction make it a practical multi-use accessory.

The main decision is fit and capacity: measure your oven rack, then compare the round cooking area with your usual batch size.

If those dimensions work for your routine, this set offers a straightforward way to add oven crisping without taking up counter space with another appliance.

Your review at a glance

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray
4.5/5

13,000+ ratings

Read Amazon Reviews

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A good fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in a standard or convection oven without adding a countertop air fryer.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round 13.12-inch overall size, designed for standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air-fry models.
  • Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating in a copper finish.
  • The pan catches grease and crumbs that fall through the basket.

Written by

foodalution.com Editorial Team

Editorial team

foodalution.com publishes practical how-to guides and educational articles with clear steps and useful context.

Amazon customer reviews

See what buyers think

Explore customer reviews, photos and available video reviews on Amazon.

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

Gotham Steel Crisper Tray

A good fit for cooks who want to crisp smaller portions in a standard or convection oven without adding a countertop air fryer.

  • Two-piece set with a raised mesh basket and solid drip pan.
  • Round 13.12-inch overall size, designed for standard oven racks, small convection ovens, and oven air-fry models.
Check Video Reviews on Amazon